Say they started to make items that are straight from the game for people to buy (collectors edition items and stuff), what would you want the most?

Personally, I'd want things like an actual "Last Window" book. Maybe a Room 215 keychain key.
I also think that Red Crown jacket looked pretty pimp, wouldn't mind having one. There are lots of things that could equate to some pretty cool merchandise.

What would you guys want?

Realistically, the key chain was a smashing idea. Though I'm uncertain, I could turn down a paper clip.

Haha, you would dare turn down a paper clip!? That's blasphemous!

The pen that Kyle finds and dusts off would be pretty cool too I think.

If not a paper clip, a coat hanger works fine as well! XD

The pistol.

Preferably, a fully functioning replica.

That and the huge wads of cash.

Angel Opening a Door?
Mila Bracelet perhaps though right now I would really do with some Whiskey.

I would absolutely spring for the Red Crown jacket! I actually tried searching for Kyle Hyde cosplay clothes online, but I came up with nothing. So sad!

I would go for a bag of cash in my toilet tank, thank you.

I'd like a replica of the crowbar stolen from Dunning's toolbox.

or a replica lead pencil, like the one from Hyde's suitcase.