Page 1 of 1[ 33 posts ]
forged evidence issue
OBJECTION.I object that is objectionable
Gender: Male
Location: UK
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Sat Feb 15, 2014 11:20 am
Posts: 202
When you have eliminated all which is impossible, then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth- Sherlock Holmes
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Scotland
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:30 pm
Posts: 14188
davech1987 wrote:
Since phoenix used forged evidence in his final trial doesnt that mean every trial he has every worked would get looked into and convictions overturned ??
Might get looked into but they'd see that all previous trials were spotless so can't see why they'd overturn all his past verdicts.
Made by Chesu+Zombee
You thought you could be safe in your courts, with your laws and attorneys to protect you. In this world only I am law, my word is fact, my power is absolute.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
davech1987 wrote:
Since phoenix used forged evidence in his final trial doesnt that mean every trial he has every worked would get looked into and convictions overturned ??
Why should they? They already disbarred him for that. What does it matter what he did previously? Especially since A) they couldn't re-disbar him for those cases and B) all those cases had the real criminal admitting their guilt 100%, so it's not like those could be overruled. It's not like he forged their admission of guilt.
Quote:
Might get looked into but they'd see that all previous trials were spotless so can't see why they'd overturn all his past verdicts.
Technically, Phoenix has been doing things that aren't allowed, too. Pressuring and badgering witnesses repeatedly, practically pulling evidence out of his ass, evidence that was not admissiable to court to begin with (1-5 not withstanding because there it was a stupid little chain like contempt of court in 1-4) because neither police or prosecution knew about them and overall doing a shitty job that just depended on dumb luck.
C-A
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Scotland
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:30 pm
Posts: 14188
CatMuto wrote:
Quote:
Might get looked into but they'd see that all previous trials were spotless so can't see why they'd overturn all his past verdicts.
Technically, Phoenix has been doing things that aren't allowed, too. Pressuring and badgering witnesses repeatedly, practically pulling evidence out of his ass, evidence that was not admissiable to court to begin with (1-5 not withstanding because there it was a stupid little chain like contempt of court in 1-4) because neither police or prosecution knew about them and overall doing a shitty job that just depended on dumb luck.
C-A
Yeah but the cases were supervised by a Judge who is in charge of punishing pressuring and badgering witnesses so as an official of the court he's already in the clear.
Made by Chesu+Zombee
You thought you could be safe in your courts, with your laws and attorneys to protect you. In this world only I am law, my word is fact, my power is absolute.
Re: forged evidence issue
I've felt worse.
Gender: None specified
Location: I'm at soup.
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2012 10:18 pm
Posts: 1666
CatMuto wrote:
all those cases had the real criminal admitting their guilt 100%, so it's not like those could be overruled. It's not like he forged their admission of guilt.
I thought you were an expert in this kind of stuff.
"It's never too late to learn that growing old doesn't have to mean growing up. Stay curious, stay weird, stay kind, and don't let anyone ever tell you you aren't smart or brave or worthy enough." -Stanford Pines, Gravity Falls
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
sumguy28 wrote:
CatMuto wrote:
all those cases had the real criminal admitting their guilt 100%, so it's not like those could be overruled. It's not like he forged their admission of guilt.
I thought you were an expert in this kind of stuff.
*shrug* We never hear of any of the guilty parties after, so even if it was a false confession and they did admit they lied during the high court where the cases are sent to (according to what is said in 1-4 and what little I looked up at one point on Japanese law system while playing through this series), they would generally tell us that they were left free. (Not counting Sahwit here cause I haven't played GK2 to that extent) Though it does make me think that maybe the cases really DO work on the concept of Phoenix just basically pulling a filibuster in court until the real killer finally cracks and admits JUST so they can get out of the room again.
C-A
Re: forged evidence issue
OBJECTION.I object that is objectionable
Gender: Male
Location: UK
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Sat Feb 15, 2014 11:20 am
Posts: 202
When you have eliminated all which is impossible, then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth- Sherlock Holmes
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
davech1987 wrote:
I can't remember the name but there is a name for something when the witness breaks down and confesses on the stand when shown evidence that links them to the crime but they belive the evidence can convict them so they confess it happens alot in perry mason I just cannot remember the name given
...why don't they just make use of their right of silence? They are allowed to not say anything if their testimony would indicate that they are guilty of a criminal act.
C-A
Re: forged evidence issue
OBJECTION.I object that is objectionable
Gender: Male
Location: UK
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Sat Feb 15, 2014 11:20 am
Posts: 202
When you have eliminated all which is impossible, then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth- Sherlock Holmes
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
davech1987 wrote:
5th amendedment the right to not incrimnate ones self in crime but then it could be seen as guilt anyway i imagine lol
Well this is the AA verse so they likely don't HAVE any rights.
C-A
Re: forged evidence issue
2008-2018
Gender: Female
Location: LA, Japanifornia
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Mon Jun 18, 2012 6:17 am
Posts: 6143
The home of the Gyakuten Saiban vs Ace Attorney blog: http://gyakutengagotoku.tumblr.com
1/3/19 edit: The project has officially been moved to a new blog at https://gsvsaa.blogspot.com/ Further updates will be pending.
AA fanfiction archive: viewtopic.php?f=11&t=31369
Yakuza/RGG fanfiction archive: https://archiveofourown.org/users/rubia ... /rubia_ryu
My misc translation and work promos here at http://rubiaryutheroyal.tumblr.com
1/3/19 edit: The project has officially been moved to a new blog at https://gsvsaa.blogspot.com/ Further updates will be pending.
AA fanfiction archive: viewtopic.php?f=11&t=31369
Yakuza/RGG fanfiction archive: https://archiveofourown.org/users/rubia ... /rubia_ryu
My misc translation and work promos here at http://rubiaryutheroyal.tumblr.com
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Scotland
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:30 pm
Posts: 14188
CatMuto wrote:
davech1987 wrote:
5th amendedment the right to not incrimnate ones self in crime but then it could be seen as guilt anyway i imagine lol
Well this is the AA verse so they likely don't HAVE any rights.
C-A
Are...are you forgetting Adrian? It was like the most memorable thing she did
Made by Chesu+Zombee
You thought you could be safe in your courts, with your laws and attorneys to protect you. In this world only I am law, my word is fact, my power is absolute.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
Pierre wrote:
CatMuto wrote:
davech1987 wrote:
5th amendedment the right to not incrimnate ones self in crime but then it could be seen as guilt anyway i imagine lol
Well this is the AA verse so they likely don't HAVE any rights.
C-A
Are...are you forgetting Adrian? It was like the most memorable thing she did
Pierre, we both know if they had proper rights in the AA verse, every single murderer would've caused a stall in the entire case by refusing to testify in the case. (And no, using your right of silence to not indicate yourself of A crime means you are guilty of THE crime) Everyone would not even dare to commit perjury cause they land in jail (only time I sorta saw this happen, off the top of my head, was April May and that felt like they merely used that background cause they didn't have a different one) and majority of evidence in the cases would never be admitted to court. (Wait that's a law procedure not a right...)
C-A
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Scotland
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:30 pm
Posts: 14188
Doesn't change the fact that Adrian explicitly states she had the right not to testify and exercised it in-game.
Seriously just face facts. There ARE rights in Ace Attorney games. We might not have the full book of them because it's a mystery drama not an actual law simulator but they are confirmed to exist in some form.
Made by Chesu+Zombee
You thought you could be safe in your courts, with your laws and attorneys to protect you. In this world only I am law, my word is fact, my power is absolute.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
Quote:
There ARE rights in Ace Attorney games
But they are so inconsistent! It's just like contempt of court in 1-4 and evidence law in 1-5. It's just a dumb leash put onto you for one case and then forgotten. Either you keep that shit in for every case or you don't put it in at all.
C-A
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Scotland
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:30 pm
Posts: 14188
CatMuto wrote:
Quote:
There ARE rights in Ace Attorney games
But they are so inconsistent! It's just like contempt of court in 1-4 and evidence law in 1-5. It's just a dumb leash put onto you for one case and then forgotten. Either you keep that shit in for every case or you don't put it in at all.
C-A
Well opinions on the laws aren't what people are discussing right now. Whether they are always exercised or not isn't the question here.
Here's what you said:
Quote:
Well this is the AA verse so they likely don't HAVE any rights.
You are outright wrong in this statement.
A correct statement would be.
"I think the laws are so inconsistent in AA that they may as well not have any rights"
Made by Chesu+Zombee
You thought you could be safe in your courts, with your laws and attorneys to protect you. In this world only I am law, my word is fact, my power is absolute.
Re: forged evidence issue
A Kirby and AA fan
Gender: Male
Location: The Netherlands
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 6:01 pm
Posts: 1032
CatMuto wrote:
Pierre, we both know if they had proper rights in the AA verse, every single murderer would've caused a stall in the entire case by refusing to testify in the case. (And no, using your right of silence to not indicate yourself of A crime means you are guilty of THE crime) Everyone would not even dare to commit perjury cause they land in jail (only time I sorta saw this happen, off the top of my head, was April May and that felt like they merely used that background cause they didn't have a different one) and majority of evidence in the cases would never be admitted to court. (Wait that's a law procedure not a right...)
Incriminate... It's incriminate. Not indicate.
Anyway, the explanation given at that time is that apparently hardly anyone would just think of pleading the fifth and that the only reason Adrian thought of doing it is because Franziska planted the idea in her head.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
Quote:
Incriminate... It's incriminate. Not indicate.
Oops. My mind was filled with the adjective indicative.
Also, how can these people not know of pleading for their right of silence?
Isn't it common knowledge that you have that? (even in Japan)
C-A
Re: forged evidence issue
2008-2018
Gender: Female
Location: LA, Japanifornia
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Mon Jun 18, 2012 6:17 am
Posts: 6143
Besides, it's impractical for the purposes of game development to rid of its reusable witnesses, even if they've been caught lying on the stand too many times to count. It's not too difficult to create new characters, since they do so anyway, but it's still more work they don't need.
So, uh, blame game mechanics?
The home of the Gyakuten Saiban vs Ace Attorney blog: http://gyakutengagotoku.tumblr.com
1/3/19 edit: The project has officially been moved to a new blog at https://gsvsaa.blogspot.com/ Further updates will be pending.
AA fanfiction archive: viewtopic.php?f=11&t=31369
Yakuza/RGG fanfiction archive: https://archiveofourown.org/users/rubia ... /rubia_ryu
My misc translation and work promos here at http://rubiaryutheroyal.tumblr.com
1/3/19 edit: The project has officially been moved to a new blog at https://gsvsaa.blogspot.com/ Further updates will be pending.
AA fanfiction archive: viewtopic.php?f=11&t=31369
Yakuza/RGG fanfiction archive: https://archiveofourown.org/users/rubia ... /rubia_ryu
My misc translation and work promos here at http://rubiaryutheroyal.tumblr.com
Re: forged evidence issue
A Kirby and AA fan
Gender: Male
Location: The Netherlands
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 6:01 pm
Posts: 1032
CatMuto wrote:
Also, how can these people not know of pleading for their right of silence?
Isn't it common knowledge that you have that? (even in Japan)
C-A
Isn't it common knowledge that you have that? (even in Japan)
C-A
I didn't say they don't know about it. I (and Phoenix) said that most people wouldn't think about doing it on the spot.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Scotland
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:30 pm
Posts: 14188
Made by Chesu+Zombee
You thought you could be safe in your courts, with your laws and attorneys to protect you. In this world only I am law, my word is fact, my power is absolute.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Spain
Rank: Medium-in-training
Joined: Tue Oct 28, 2014 7:38 pm
Posts: 477
And, well, when Adrian used her right, she ended up being harassed and character-assasinated by both defense and prosecution and became a main suspect, so...it wasn't really a good idea.
But seriously, the gameplay is based in finding contradictions in testimonies. It would be hard to do that if the witnesses just refused to testify.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
Pierre wrote:
People might even be aware but know that refusing to testify would look super incriminating on their behalf.
And yet, despite finding lie after lie in the testimony, the Judge still allows them (and swallows) their testimony so easily... nobody ever really says, "You've already been caught lying on the stand, we'll find it hard to believe another word out of you". Judgey may say "Please tell us the truth now..." but... I dunno, it's not really forceful.
Quote:
And, well, when Adrian used her right, she ended up being harassed and character-assasinated by both defense and prosecution and became a main suspect, so...it wasn't really a good idea.
I find that a bad example, not just because any lawyer (prosecution or defense) who would begin to reveal personal medical issues of a witness and badger them that openly would lose their badge faster than you can say Misham... but also, we're kinda supposed to see 2-4 as an extreme case of the exception. After all, both Phoenix and Edgey are practically blackmailed into doing whatever it takes to put the blame onto the wrong person. They don't really care if they are doing something wrong, they're doing it cause they have to.
So 2-4 is a bad example to pick what refusal to testify can bring, unless we took it as an example of Phoenix' whining.
C-A
PS: Also I keep writing testimoney first... damn lack of sleep.
Re: forged evidence issue
A Kirby and AA fan
Gender: Male
Location: The Netherlands
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 6:01 pm
Posts: 1032
CatMuto wrote:
And yet, despite finding lie after lie in the testimony, the Judge still allows them (and swallows) their testimony so easily... nobody ever really says, "You've already been caught lying on the stand, we'll find it hard to believe another word out of you". Judgey may say "Please tell us the truth now..." but... I dunno, it's not really forceful.
It's semi-implied that the judge we all know and love is kind of a special case, what having both the nicknames Judge Fickle and The Great Judgini, if I am not mistaken. And the fact that the Judge basically allows any kind of abuse to himself.
It's very well possible that these things are not permissible under any other Judge's ruling and that this is the sole reason the true culprit gets basically infinite chances to redeem themselves. We're talking about Judge Fickle (and The Great Judgini), after all!
CatMuto wrote:
So 2-4 is a bad example to pick what refusal to testify can bring, unless we took it as an example of Phoenix' whining.
See, it's things like this that irk me. You always have to take a jab at others (be them fictional characters or not) without reason or relevance.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
Quote:
It's very well possible that these things are not permissible under any other Judge's ruling
*cough judge's brother in 3-4 and 3-5*
Quote:
See, it's things like this that irk me. You always have to take a jab at others (be them fictional characters or not) without reason or relevance.
Please tell me you aren't the type to have your feelings hurt when someone insults fictional characters.
Also, we were talking about 2-4 being an example of things. I pointed out how 2-4 is a terrible case to pick as your example since most of things there are so contrived only due to blackmail, that we know that without the blackmail, MAJORITY of the issues would disappear, so things like Adrian refusing to testify would not have mattered so much.
So I fail to see how there was no relevance, since I pointed out what 2-4 WOULD be a good example of.
C-A
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Scotland
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:30 pm
Posts: 14188
Yeah the judges brother is quite dumb but it's not the same situation. You can't say it was permissible under that judge just because both have some blunderous moments as well.
Made by Chesu+Zombee
You thought you could be safe in your courts, with your laws and attorneys to protect you. In this world only I am law, my word is fact, my power is absolute.
Re: forged evidence issue
A Kirby and AA fan
Gender: Male
Location: The Netherlands
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 6:01 pm
Posts: 1032
CatMuto wrote:
*cough judge's brother in 3-4 and 3-5*
Dahlia, pretty much the culprit who could charm any man... And in 3-5 Bikini was not covering up for anyone and really tried to tell the truth as she saw it.
CatMuto wrote:
Please tell me you aren't the type to have your feelings hurt when someone insults fictional characters.
I said it irked me, not offended me. And it's not even about the insulting of fictional characters... It's about your seemingly pathological need to point out their stupidities and weaknesses at every opportunity you get, whether it's relevant or not.
CatMuto wrote:
Also, we were talking about 2-4 being an example of things. I pointed out how 2-4 is a terrible case to pick as your example since most of things there are so contrived only due to blackmail, that we know that without the blackmail, MAJORITY of the issues would disappear, so things like Adrian refusing to testify would not have mattered so much.
Then you have a problem in wording things. How did "2-4 is an example of Phoenix's whining" imply all this?
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
Quote:
Then you have a problem in wording things. How did "2-4 is an example of Phoenix's whining" imply all this?
Cause we were talking about 2-4 and how it was an example of something?
C-A
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Scotland
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:30 pm
Posts: 14188
CatMuto wrote:
Quote:
Then you have a problem in wording things. How did "2-4 is an example of Phoenix's whining" imply all this?
Cause we were talking about 2-4 and how it was an example of something?
C-A
Notice, Nurio how she has clipped down your post to the least-relevant-to-the-matter-at-hand one and answered it to keep up the pretense of an argument while not conceding points she might not have any answer to?
Made by Chesu+Zombee
You thought you could be safe in your courts, with your laws and attorneys to protect you. In this world only I am law, my word is fact, my power is absolute.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Spain
Rank: Medium-in-training
Joined: Tue Oct 28, 2014 7:38 pm
Posts: 477
Nurio wrote:
CatMuto wrote:
*cough judge's brother in 3-4 and 3-5*
Dahlia, pretty much the culprit who could charm any man... And in 3-5 Bikini was not covering up for anyone and really tried to tell the truth as she saw it.
Going a bit offtopic, I've always wondered why nobody sides with Mia. She's been canonically defined as very attractive. Why only Gumshoe is affected by it?
And now back on topic, Gant also used his right to remain silent in 1-5. I don't recall if they say the same in 2-4, but when he did it, it was stated that if you use your right to remain silent, you're renouncing to your right of defending yourself against any accusations and that's why people usually don't do it.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Male
Location: Scotland
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:30 pm
Posts: 14188
luck wrote:
Nurio wrote:
CatMuto wrote:
*cough judge's brother in 3-4 and 3-5*
Dahlia, pretty much the culprit who could charm any man... And in 3-5 Bikini was not covering up for anyone and really tried to tell the truth as she saw it.
Going a bit offtopic, I've always wondered why nobody sides with Mia. She's been canonically defined as very attractive. Why only Gumshoe is affected by it?
And now back on topic, Gant also used his right to remain silent in 1-5. I don't recall if they say the same in 2-4, but when he did it, it was stated that if you use your right to remain silent, you're renouncing to your right of defending yourself against any accusations and that's why people usually don't do it.
It's easier to have a stigma against the defence for defending people they know they are guilty. Whereas Prosecution are pro-active in making people guilty.
As they say "queue like an execution", folks love to see 'justice'.
Made by Chesu+Zombee
You thought you could be safe in your courts, with your laws and attorneys to protect you. In this world only I am law, my word is fact, my power is absolute.
Re: forged evidence issue
Gender: Female
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 2:23 pm
Posts: 9882
Quote:
Going a bit offtopic, I've always wondered why nobody sides with Mia. She's been canonically defined as very attractive. Why only Gumshoe is affected by it?
I think it was because we're supposed to believe that Dahlia exuded (ex... cuded...? ...gave off) an aura of complete serenity and cuteness that it made her look even hotter than Mia?
Quote:
And now back on topic, Gant also used his right to remain silent in 1-5. I don't recall if they say the same in 2-4, but when he did it, it was stated that if you use your right to remain silent, you're renouncing to your right of defending yourself against any accusations and that's why people usually don't do it.
Yeah that part never made sense to me in 1-5. Using your right to remain silent means you refuse to answer questions that could potentially incriminate you of a crime, but that doesn't mean you are willy-nilly going to sit there (or be forced to), taking all kinds of accusations that might have nothing to do with anything. You are allowed to defend your own character as this could be seen as slander.
C-A
Re: forged evidence issue
A Kirby and AA fan
Gender: Male
Location: The Netherlands
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 6:01 pm
Posts: 1032
luck wrote:
Going a bit offtopic, I've always wondered why nobody sides with Mia. She's been canonically defined as very attractive. Why only Gumshoe is affected by it?
On top of what everyone else has said, Mia also didn't really actively try to charm anyone.
(Also, Diego was affected by Mia's attractiveness too.)
CatMuto wrote:
Yeah that part never made sense to me in 1-5. Using your right to remain silent means you refuse to answer questions that could potentially incriminate you of a crime, but that doesn't mean you are willy-nilly going to sit there (or be forced to), taking all kinds of accusations that might have nothing to do with anything. You are allowed to defend your own character as this could be seen as slander.
It's actually only slander if they're false claims with the intent to drag someone through the mud. If they're true accusations, it's not slander.
Page 1 of 1
[ 33 posts ]
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum
News
Site map
SitemapIndex
RSS Feed