Board index » Present Evidence » Present Testimony

Page 1 of 1[ 15 posts ]
 


Bottled Love (2nd chapter up)Topic%20Title
User avatar

*c a n d l e

Gender: Female

Location: In the candlelight

Rank: Medium-in-training

Joined: Mon Apr 07, 2008 12:34 am

Posts: 572

I was replaying Trials and Tribulations and suddenly it occured to me that Dahlia really never had her say in anything, such as whether she loved or detested Phoenix or whether she felt guilty about her victims. I decided to write up a a fanfiction about how she really felt on the inside and how she really isn't a demon or the female devil. It's written directly from her perspective. =)
Cases: References for cases 3-1, 3-3, and 3-5
Main characters: Dahlia Hawthorne, Phoenix Wright, Iris, Doug Swallow
Summary: Memories of Phoenix, Dahlia's previous love, fill her mind everyday and it tortures her soul to watch him down below. Instead of crying and having a shadow of grief surrounding her, she instead envisages how she could've loved Phoenix, but she never got the chance.
It only has one curse so far, so I guess I can consider it to be PG. Oh, and it contains SPOILERS every now and then. Enjoy! Criticism and comments appreciated!

Bottled Love

It hurt. It was painful like I way I had treated others. Guilt gnawed at my bleeding heart and it would never stop. I wanted it to stop, to stop so badly. My throat tightened at the thought of him…Feenie…Phoenix… Alternatively, the way he had called me Dollie when I had been with him two times. Twice in my life, that feeling of passion had burned through my heart. Now where was my heart again?

I laughed; a raspy, taciturn chuckle that sent goose bumps to all parts of my body. It was not humorous to me, just depressing. I did not know why it was depressing…and that made me as frustrated as a famished wolf. My knees unbuckled; I collapsed to the ground. What was this feeling? I cannot remember. Feenie? Dammit, where are you? Where are you? Hysteria clouded my brain. Throughout the next few minutes, I was sobbing cascading waterfalls, cackling like a lunatic. Stop it…stop it!

I could hear Phoenix‘s—my Feenie’s—voice murmuring to me. I felt wonderful. I could hear myself talking in a faraway reminiscence.

Hey, Dollie, what’cha thinking about?” Feenie had smiled, so warmly, as he took my hand.

I’m watching the birds fly. It’s sad.” I remember shedding a tear. Feenie had tucked a stray piece of my crimson hair behind my ear.

They’ll come back, Dollie, they’ll come back…”

I don’t remember him saying this. One name echoed in my mind, chanting repeatedly: Iris.

I believe you, Feenie. I love you,” my sister had whispered. All three of the last words were both of ours.

Iris…

If I had the chance to slay again, you would be my victim. You stole everything from me, sister…my reveries, my psyche…my Feenie.

* * *

I was shaking from head to toe. This was the day that I would be able to see Phoenix Wright again. Three hours before the current time of eight o’clock, Iris had suspiciously let me go to his school. As I had left, I heard her whisper hoarsely to me, “act like I would.” Those words made me giggle mentally. I had to act like her. Nevertheless, I knew that if I did not act innocently, someone would see through my mask. Iris told me that she would call me on my cell phone during lunch.

My hands were quivering as I took out the cell phone. A garbage can was nearby to my right and I smiled wickedly; I had won this battle over Iris. I tossed the phone into the garbage, and when no one was around, I put my hand into it and made sure that papers covered it. Satisfied, with Iris’ voice tranquilizing gradually, I entered through the doors of Ivy University.

“Dahlia Hawthorne?” A husky, somber voice startled me. In terror, I dropped my umbrella to the floor, my heart pounding through my body. My carmine eyes swiftly inspected the man, instantly recognizing him as Professor Lydae. I cleared my throat and bent down to pick up the umbrella, smiling innocuously.

“Professor, you startled me,” I said politely. He stiffened and stood up from the desk he was sitting at, scowling into my eyes.

“Miss Hawthorne, as a scholar here at Ivy University, you should comprehend that no student is permitted to flow through these doors. I advocate that you purchase spectacles, as there are three words sprawled across these doors. Care to read them?” Professor Lydae’s eyes scorched into mine. He tapped his left wellington boot on the tiled floor.

“It must have slipped my mind. Please excuse me,” I replied with a thin smile. Before I could get the chance to walk away, he grabbed my shoulder.

“The bell, Miss Hawthorne.”

“The bell-?” For a moment, I was utterly bemused before a ring screamed in my ears. My whole body reacted—I jerked against the wall. The professor stared at me closely before shaking his head briskly. He shoved a piece of paper in my hand and rushed me off with a wave.

Dahlia Hawthorne to Room 105, Time and Date: 8:04 on May 3, Professor Lydae, Late Pass

Embarrassed, I exited the doors and wound up having extreme difficulty finding my first period class. Iris had not given me any warnings that there was not a single map at the university and I soundlessly held a worthless grudge against her; again. Irritated at my sister’s trick, which I would’ve never guessed she would have the valor to do, I sidestepped into yet another set of silver doors, hoping this time I was in the right place. With my black cat luck, it was probably the cafeteria or library, so I was astonished that, indeed, it was Room 105, the English room.

My face turned carnation red from forehead to chin as I scampered over to the front desk of the classroom. Everyone was gawking at me, probably surprised that I was being so clumsy. They made me uncomfortable and I tripped over my futile shoes. The white butterflies on them had rubbed together or my feet had fallen over someone’s desk. A familiar laugh filled my ears and let tears fall down my cheek. I turned away to avoid even more humiliation. The professor two feet away from me, Mrs. Groven, took the note with a slight grin and patted my back, in an effort to hide my weeping.

As I turned my torso to face the class, one face caught my eye instantly. It was Doug Swallow, my worst nightmare. He had been my boyfriend one year ago, which, fortunately, didn’t exasperate Phoenix. Everyday, down here or up there, Doug was the one who haunted me. Daylight or twilight, his face was there. His small brown eyes, his light brown hair, his red jacket, his love for Great Britain. I remember him accusing me of trying to poison him, but now he seemed like a friend. Doug smiled at me and I looked away, afraid that he would see through me; that he would see that Iris and I were the same person.

I was so caught up in my trepidation that Mrs. Groven cleared her throat and ushered me to my seat. She could feel the tension rise between Phoenix and I and she coughed. Phoenix was talking to someone familiar. I felt a sneeze coming. It came out at over eighty miles per hour and it attracted his attention, but he blocked the female’s face. His whole face glowed with contentment and it tore my heart into two pieces.

The darkness came over me. I didn’t want my ire to be exposed in front of twenty college students and a teacher. Graciously, I inquired, “Mrs. Groven, may I please change my seat for today? I am feeling quite ill and I would prefer it if I was further away from the other students here, please.” Fighting the urge to be icy, I smiled amiably at her.

My face was completely frozen in the smile as she studied me for ten, seemingly endless moments. Finally, the torture ended and she nodded.

“Would you like to go to the nurse’s office?” she asked. Her face was clouded in pure worry, nothing else.

“Yes,” I verbalized brusquely. Before she had the attempt to stop me, I was already out the door, feeling my face turn carnation yet again. The two people who still stared in my direction even as Mrs. Grover began the lesson were Doug and Feenie.

Image

私達に信頼を与えるキャンドルライト...


Last edited by lapis lazuli on Thu Jun 19, 2008 8:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

f l o w e r y *

Gender: Female

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Sun Jun 08, 2008 9:39 pm

Posts: 9

I give the first chapter of Bottled Love an 8.8/10. Before I state my reasons, I would like to know why you called this fanfiction "Bottled Love" in the first place. My curiousity does get to the best of me sometimes, but I'm sure that whoever read this was wondering the same thing. I suppose I will do a postives/negatives sort of thing. Here I go...I mean, you did want criticism and comments, so might as well do both. >.<

Positives
·Excellent details
·Peculiar yet creative idea
·Simple fascinating to read about Dahlias thoughts and feelings
·Has personality and character without a doubt
·Truly makes you think about how people like Dahlia really have emotions

Negatives
·A bit on the short side
·Dialouge isn't flowing correctly; very choppy
·As much as you want Dahlia to seem innocent, you still make her malicious
·Emotions are too heavy to be considered "love"
·Obviously confusing

:that-b-word:
Image
Beautiful signature made by the wonderful and talented Vickinator
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

*c a n d l e

Gender: Female

Location: In the candlelight

Rank: Medium-in-training

Joined: Mon Apr 07, 2008 12:34 am

Posts: 572

Thanks for being the first to actually post. ... I wasn't expecting some of the negatives that you put down, such as confusing, heavy love, and choppy dialouge. Let me clear this up a little:

Dahlia is only envisaging what she wanted to happen between Phoenix and her. Obviously, this can never happen because she's too far away to be with him. It's almost like she's taking a trip through the past, making things correct. It's a fanFICTION, so in other words, it's not true. fantasy. fake. a faux. Understand? If it's that hard to comprehend, please don't be afraid to PM me.
Now, the heavy love. Isn't love and emotions supposed to be rich with passion? Dahlia's emotions aren't heavy and obscure, rather filled with passion burning in her heart. She wants Phoenix to love her more than Iris; it's a competition between the two, but Iris knows to back off. Dahlia's "heavy love" is just a way of showing that she heavily loves her Feenie.
I know it's on the short side...
You said that it had personality and character, yet you say it's choppy? There's hardly any dialouge, so I don't really know what's so bad about it...
Perennial wrote:
·As much as you want Dahlia to seem innocent, you still make her malicious

Spoiler: T&T
Dahlia's not supposed to seem innocent. I just wanted readers to not think of her as the b word. Dahlia's true personality is in fact malicious, but it's not always murderous. She's cold, she's emotionless, she's violent at times, but I don't want her to be innocent. She's not innocent; I wanted to bring out her side of the story.


Thanks very much though!
Oh, and there's no meaning to the title of it.
Image

私達に信頼を与えるキャンドルライト...
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title

Detective... Well, not yet.

Gender: None specified

Rank: Desk Jockey

Joined: Sat Jun 07, 2008 6:08 pm

Posts: 60

IT's a bit choppy but it's great! UPDATE!
viewtopic.php?f=11&t=9912 < --- Franziska X Phoenix Fan Fiction =P

<insert awesome signature that totally PWNS here>
Current AA Project: Turnabout... Love?
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title

True love is forever.

Gender: Female

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Tue Oct 30, 2007 4:55 am

Posts: 2182

I think this is an interesting interpretation of Dahlia and quite well-written except for a few minor grammatical problems. My biggest issue is that Dahlia's characterization seems... a bit off (that may simply be because your interpretation of Dahlia by this time differs some from my own and if that is the issue then I'll leave it alone). I just have trouble viewing her thoughts towards Phoenix that way considering what we see of her in the game and what we know of her development up to that time. You've got a good start though. I look forward to more. :)
Proud Supporter of Phoenix/Iris, Ron/Dessie, Klavier/Ema, and Apollo/Vera
Fanfics Updated-12/25
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

In Justice We Trust

Gender: Male

Location: Southern California

Rank: Admin

Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 6:31 pm

Posts: 4215

Not to burst your bubble or anything, but I distinctly recall something that was said in Bridge to the Turnabout.

Spoiler: 3-5
In the Inner Temple, when Phoenix was questioning "Iris," he asked her if Dahlia had told her anything about him. "Iris" replied (with an innocent smile, if I recall correctly) that Dahlia had told her that she "hated his guts."


I won't use that as an excuse to criticize your story, though. My only criticism is that while I acknowledge that Dahlia behaves that way outwardly, I had trouble believing that her thoughts were the same as the ones expressed through your story.
Image
I'll always love you, Max.
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

*c a n d l e

Gender: Female

Location: In the candlelight

Rank: Medium-in-training

Joined: Mon Apr 07, 2008 12:34 am

Posts: 572

Thanks for the comments, as always. I'll be sure to follow the advice given to me. =)
Image

私達に信頼を与えるキャンドルライト...
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

Gender: None specified

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Thu Nov 15, 2007 2:25 am

Posts: 3541

Bit of a unique take on Dollie. I'm interested to see how it turns out.

And happy birthday :butzthumbs:
Image
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

f l o w e r y *

Gender: Female

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Sun Jun 08, 2008 9:39 pm

Posts: 9

You are quite the determined one, eh? How you would make an excellent defense attorney; I agree with your case on the fanfiction. =) Feliciations on your birthday, as well.
Oh, and before I forget, it would be wise to post a link of the fanfiction on Fanfiction.net, as I'm presuming your avatar is a spoiler. Maybe you'll even be banned?
Anywho, I look forward to seeing more of Bottled Love.
Image
Beautiful signature made by the wonderful and talented Vickinator
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

Cherryberry

Gender: Female

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Thu May 01, 2008 8:52 pm

Posts: 20

Thanks for the happy birthdays!
Hey, Perennial, in English, that's what we call "foreshadowing." =) This is lapis lazuli using her sister's account. Seems like my avatar was indeed a spoiler, but I'm not mad about it or anything. I've completed the second chapter to Bottled Love, and someone's question about the title will be answered. Enjoy!

Chapter 2

I didn’t know where the nurse’s office was either. Then again, I had no idea where anything was at Ivy University. As I passed the garbage can from before, I heard it playing the ludicrous Steel Samurai ringtone. If Feenie had a cell phone, it would probably have to match mine. I smiled at the thought and quickly dug the phone out of the garbage can. A janitor was adjacent, but he ignored me and continued with his sweeping around the campus.

The phone had begun to vibrate in my hands. Iris was calling me hours early. Could she really be this worried about our identity? I answered it on around the twentieth ring.

“Hello?” I whispered. My feet carried me along to an oak tree a few meters away. I felt secure and hidden underneath the shade of the forest green leaves sheltering over me.

“Dahlia, I was so worried!” Her voice came out as practically a scream. I could imagine that Iris had been crying since I had left.

“Calm down already,” I retorted impatiently. If anyone was listening to me they would know my true personality, but right now, I didn’t stress over it.

“I-I was worried about you!” Iris wailed, though the sobs stopped.

“I was gone for not even an hour, you idiotic sister!” My face was obviously flushed from shrieking into the phone.

Iris was silent for countless minutes. I was breathing heavily, hoping that she wouldn’t say anything else and hang up.

“I’m sorry,” she finally whispered. I heard a small sob in the background, probably her crying quietly again. “Why are you doing this?” There’s my answer of why she had called. I could detect melancholy and slight rage in her petite voice.

“In case you haven’t noticed, I’m the one asking questions.” My eyes scanned all around me, cautious of anyone approaching. I cringed as a shadow approached. “I have to go.”

“Wait!-”

I hung up on her, tossed the cell phone behind me, and walked towards the “stranger,” whom I immediately identified as the one I lost. Phoenix Wright was clad in his usual fluffy cerise sweater, a red heart stamped onto the middle with a distinctive yellow "P" in it. A matching carmine scarf hugged at his neck loosely, nearly flying off as he ran towards me, happiness bubbling outside of him with every step he took. Blue denim jeans snugged in long legs and his "P" midnight blue and cerulean sneakers took out like a reddened thumb. For once, he actually wasn't wearing a mask to hide his cough. Not even his daily dose of Coldkiller X was around, as I couldn't smell its wrathful stench.

Although seeing him made me feel my heart sew itself together, stitch by stitch, I felt an emotion that I hadn't felt in such a long while, culpability. To encourage him, I smiled lovingly and picked up the oyster and salmon lace umbrella. As he approached, I felt my eyebrows squirm continually from regular to a frown. His breath had the sordid aroma of flowers, which I detested so. My body nearly recoiled away from him on reflex and by the time I had controlled my nervous system to stop, he was already eyeing me with skepticism. I stared into his shining brown eyes, forcing my own to glitter back like the stars in a night sky. The suspicion drained from him at once.

He greeted me with an embrace. I vacillated for a few seconds, swaying from side to side, until finally Feenie let go.

"Dollie...?" His brows knitted together, developing a plan. Then he attempted to kiss me on the cheek but I pulled away, my arms accidentally pushing him two inches from me. "Did I do something wrong?" He was on the threshold of crying.

"Feenie, I haven't been feeling that good," I replied. Had he forgotten? "I was about to go to the nurse's office but the fresh air was my actual remedy, not some silly pills or whatnot. Can you please, please forgive me so?"

I saw hesitation in him like I had been so tentative only moments ago, but his didn't last as long. As he tried to embrace me again, his eyes were visibly cautious, fearful, and saddened. To comfort him, I hugged him back, but ever so loosely. Just in case a certain twin was eavesdropping and watching down upon the two of us. I nearly jumped at the sound of a certain Steel Samurai ring-tone, but Feenie was unfazed, as if he didn't hear it; the cell phone was practically a screaming girl behind us, waiting dejectedly for me to pick her up.

Feenie's buoyancy revived shortly after. "Do you wanna borrow some of my Coldkiller X? It really works, you know. The nurse, Ms. Anyie, she actually gave it to me. Not my doctor. Oh, wait...you already knew this, now didn't you, Dollie? I sound so senseless, so absurd, now don't I?"

I myself was beginning to get vexed. Accommodatingly I nodded with a thin smile that I felt slithering across my lips. "Actually, I was just about to head over to Nurse Anyie just now. Please excuse me, Feenie." I turned to dart away from him but a familiar umbrella landed in front of my face. My irises wavered around me, staring at both him and my lace parasol.

"I-I have a gift for you, so just, um, wait a sec, okay?" he stuttered, hem and haw sticking to his voice.

"...Okay then." A gift? Lovely. Just absolutely perfect. Sure, I wanted to spend as much time with him as I could, but I just couldn't shake the feeling that Iris was...watching us, envy clawing at her painfully. Her violet eyes wide with hurt and revenge. I precluded a giggle. Iris? Revenge? Those two words put together in a sentence was quite preposterous. The though left me as I turned to face Feenie.

"Close you eyes," he instructed firmly. I sighed, closed my eyes stubbornly, and listened without an ounce of patience to his shuffling hands in his Denim pockets. "Here." I was nearly speechless as he shoved an item into my waiting hands. "You can open your eyes now." I did exactly what I was told to, my heart racing with excitement, and as my eyes opened, the refreshing breezes welcoming them, I gasped in amazement and bliss. Sitting in my hands was the best gift I had ever received since I had been a child.

It was a clear glass bottle with a cork sealing air inside of it, like the kind collectors would try to assemble a small ship in it. Glued to the sides of the bottle were claret, raspberry, and ivory colored rose petals, not decaying from the lack of water yet, and they were arranged in numerous words. I read them out loud, much to Feenie's discomfiture: Dahlia, Love, Forever, Red, Cherish, and Heart. My eyes were swollen within two seconds after finishing the words. "There's one last word underneath," Feenie pointed out, his eyes shifting from side to side nervously. I glanced, flipping the bottle over, and read the final name with my breath dry: Phoenix. A tear rolled down my cheek. Phoenix, like the mythological bird that never dies, no matter what happens to it. They will always burn themselves into their own ashes, only to reappear and live for another five-hundred years. "Don't forget to open it, Dollie," Feenie teased playfully, taking a step forward. He swiftly took the bottle out of my shaky hands, just about ready to drop and break it, and popped open the cork. The sweet aroma of dahlias filled my mind with wonder. For once the scent smelt good to my nose.

Feenie gave me a present that had miraculously fit inside the fragile bottle. He watched with upmost delight as I slowly opened the box, colorfully decorated with matching claret dahlia petals this time. Underneath the layers of wrapping was the most beautiful and small glass sculpture I had ever seen. It was clear but had vivid color and I was curious to know how they had done that without breaking it. The sculpture was of a phoenix, the legendary bird of fire, spreading its magnificent wings, ready to hover in the sky, guarding over the animals below. Next to the phoenix was a glass bouqet of dahlias; inside of them were every color someone could imagine. All the colors of the spectral danced as I turned it into the sunlight, rays of warmth glittering and reflecting off of the sculpture. The phoenix's wings were vividly colored in with the hues of fire, red, orange, yellow, even those rare ones such as purple and green. In the phoenix's front plummage and the single red dahlia in the middle of the bouqet were two noticeable hearts that seem to glow with passion.

"The bottle stands for our love," Feenie murmured against my ear. "I'm the phoenix and you're the dahlia. Inseparable for all eternity."

"Bottled love," I repeated in a whisper. The tears ran down my cheeks endlessly, dropping down onto the exquisite glass, making it possibly even more beautiful than it already had been. "Thank you...I love you very much, Feenie."

Image
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

f l o w e r y *

Gender: Female

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Sun Jun 08, 2008 9:39 pm

Posts: 9

Though seemingly impossible, you've actually improved over the course of a single chapter. I shall raise my review for Bottled Love to a 9.0. The second chapter was more smooth with the dialouge, as it is now on the verge of becoming great, but there's still some rough edges around the corners. Details are excellent and I especially adored the part when Phoenix gives Dahlia the gift. I simply was not expecting that to be why the title is what it is. My only problem is the way that Dahlia had so abruptly hung up on Iris, though that would indeed be the way she would have. And I do have two small inquiries: does Dahlia live with Iris? and when Dahlia interrupted her sister, was Iris giving her a warning? It's fine if you don't desire to answer, as I am patient and would love to read the answer for myself. =D
Image
Beautiful signature made by the wonderful and talented Vickinator
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title

True love is forever.

Gender: Female

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Tue Oct 30, 2007 4:55 am

Posts: 2182

I think this story is very cute and well-written. I do still have some issues with Dahlia's characterization, but that might just be me so I'll leave it alone. I do also have a couple issues with content though. The first is why wouldn't Dahlia know the campus when she had to be the one attending the school? Iris is asked directly about whether she went to college (Phoenix might even use the college's name) and she says no, yet no psyche-locks appear which tells us that Iris was telling the truth there (this is furthered by the fact that the magatama is clearly functioning as it activates only a few moments later when Phoenix asks Iris if she knows him and they appear). So Dahlia was the one attending the university. My only other issue is that Iris knows Dahlia is near Phoenix and does nothing besides being somewhat concerned? Iris states that had she known about Dahlia's plans to kill Phoenix, then she would have killed her sister or died herself to protect him. “Why are you doing this?” Does Iris suspect Dahlia in your story? If she does then the story is a bit inconsistent with canon because she would not simply have stood by while Dahlia killed Phoenix even if she was a distance away. If she was willing to kill her sister to protect Phoenix, then I think by that point she would be willing to warn Phoenix that he was in danger or call the cops. Other then that, I like the story even if I don't fully agree with your interpretations of Dahlia. :)
Proud Supporter of Phoenix/Iris, Ron/Dessie, Klavier/Ema, and Apollo/Vera
Fanfics Updated-12/25
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

Cherryberry

Gender: Female

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Thu May 01, 2008 8:52 pm

Posts: 20

Before I answer your questions, I would like to say something: I do not support Phoenix x Dahlia in any way, shape, or form. Personally, I prefer Phoenix x Iris, just to clear things up. =)
You know, I haven't really thought too deeply into this or how much my fanfiction intertwines with Trials and Tribulations. I have a solution, but, of course, I'll gladly clear things up. When I was first writing the story, I knew that the short prolouge in the first chapter (with Dahlia wishing that things went her way) was how she had somewhat acted in the game. When her personality completely switches over as the story progresses, she acts more like Iris would to Phoenix. Remember: I believe I noted somewhere that this was all part of Dahlia's, um...dreams, I suppose. Lost memories of Phoenix and partially Iris. She imagines Phoenix being her one true love, when, in reality, of course that never happens. They are almost literally on two seperate planets. Right now, I'm actually confusing myself horribly. To put it simply, Dahlia's envisaging that she is Iris and Iris is the one who has to watch her sister be with Phoenix, even though it's completely the other way around. Dahlia wouldn't know the campus because, well, this is where I changed the storyline quite a bit from the game. Here, Iris was pretending to be Dahlia because at first, Dahlia intentionally "hated Phoenix's guts" and wanted Iris to be her minion basically. However, watching Iris and Phoenix being happy together triggered something in Dahlia's mind: jealousy. So, in actuality, Dahlia does hate Phoenix in this story but she also wants to love him, like she knows that fate will seperate them. And finally yes, Iris suspects Dahlia in the story. In a way. They're actually pretty close sisters in my story. Kind of contradictory, but Iris just so happened to nurse Dahlia back to health. Their bond will show in the third or fourth chapter, I promise.
That was confusing, wasn't it?
Image
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

Sig and Avie created by awesome Vicki!!

Gender: Female

Location: If I'm Online, I must be at my computer (duh)

Rank: Medium-in-training

Joined: Mon Mar 24, 2008 8:46 pm

Posts: 598

I personally am liking what I'm reading. At first glance, your characterization of Dahlia seems slightly... contradictory, in that you make her seem to be in love with Phoenix, yet at the same time not. But your explanations have helped clear that up (it makes sense, don't worry :garyuu: ). I think that her reaction to the present wasn't necessarily wrong, but in my humble opinion, she'd probably be happy not because of the content of the present, but perhaps because she got something from Nick that her sister didn't. From your explanations, it sounds like you're trying to characterize Dahlia's intentions of loving/being with Nick simply to make Iris jealous, since she was jealous of Iris's happiness; in effect, I'm inferring that she wanted to take Iris's happiness away. Perhaps there's even a small part of Dahlia that yearns for some sort of "love" with someone, but with her personality, that would be rather difficult to achieve.

I can see how you could really probe into Dahlia's psyche. In that she originally wanted Nick for her own to strike back at Iris, but then she discovers that maybe the real reason she truly wants Nick is because she wants the feeling of being loved, something she didn't earn from her family (besides perhaps Iris, but you're portraying Iris a little differently than what she is canon. It's not wrong; just a little different). Anyway, I have this strange interest in psychology, so these sort of things (I call these types of fanfics 'Character Focuses'; hence why my current fanfic is called a 'Manfred Focus') absolutely intrigue me.

Anyway, I think that you have very interesting ideas about Dahlia's feelings (I may not necessarily agree with them, but I love exploring what other people think/write about characters) about these canon situations. And while it may not quite follow canon, it doesn't necessarily have to, especially if you don't really want it to. I think to clear up confusion, you might want to add "Slightly AU" so that people won't ask about it :edgy: In any case, I'm eager to see how you keep going with this idea. The only criticism I have is that you may want to make sure your explanations you've given match the story a little better; it was a little confusing until you explained it in a separate post. But otherwise, I don't find the dialogue that choppy; is it perhaps the fact that you've centered your writing that it looks like that? :yuusaku: Also, a technique I do with dialogue is to keep all of it together (ie no spacing between each person talking) and unless there's a bunch of description after someone talks, to just keep it together. Does that make sense? It may help the choppiness. Then again, I'm not sure what exactly is the problem, but it may help.

Keep it up! :franny:
Image
NEW:V-Day Drabbles! | Flawless Achievement | These Wounds Can Heal | When the Wall Crumbles
Daughter of Xero and Mystic Mina. Sister of Lana & Ulala
Re: Bottled Love (1st chapter completed)Topic%20Title
User avatar

Cherryberry

Gender: Female

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Thu May 01, 2008 8:52 pm

Posts: 20

Thanks a million for the comments~! Personally, I like spacing out dialouge because it's easy on my eyes; I'm practically blind without my glasses. I don't know where the choppiness is coming from either, then again, I really detest proofreading my work over and over again. For this story, I didn't proof it once at all. It really distracts and irritates me when I do that. =)
Like I said before, I'm not using too much characterization from the game. It's not helping the story much anyway, so I just decided to nearly exclude it all. Dahlia is happy with two things: that she got a present from Phoenix and that Iris didn't get anything, but I also hate expressing a character's feelings. I am really horrible at that.
Oh, and I do believe that Dahlia is a notorious person, but I thought that it would be fun to see what she could be like. In other words, this story is basically pointless to express how I feel about Dahlia. I don't like her at all. >.<
Image
Page 1 of 1 [ 15 posts ] 
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  

 Board index » Present Evidence » Present Testimony

Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 30 guests

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum
Jump to:  
cron
News News Site map Site map SitemapIndex SitemapIndex RSS Feed RSS Feed Channel list Channel list
Powered by phpBB

phpBB SEO