Board index » Phoenix Wright » Defendant's Lobby

Page 2 of 4[ 149 posts ]
Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
 


Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Ema has a hat!

Gender: Male

Location: London

Rank: Decisive Witness

Joined: Mon Feb 04, 2008 10:18 am

Posts: 239

I always make sure to suspect the butterfly. Because nobody ever suspects the butterfly >:D
I'm not coming back. I'm done with this fanbase. You're all up-tight, nit-picking, hypocrites who are TERRIFIED of change. Getting banned just for standing up for myself... I'm never coming back. Goodbye forever you brats.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Gender: None specified

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Sat Jul 11, 2009 8:33 pm

Posts: 41

Pretty much I suspect the first suspicious person.
Spoiler:
1-1 Sahwit, obviously XD
1-2 Grossberg
1-3 Oldbag XDXD
1-4 Lotta
1-5 Angel
2-1 Wellington, because it's obvious
2-2 Ini Miney (actually... I haven't finished JFA yet, I just got it, but from my understanding it was actually Morgan?)
3-1 How could it NOT be Dahlia?
3-2 Ron or Atmey, I wasn't sure. >.>
3-3 Armstrong
3-4 Dahlia, because I had spoilers
3-5 Iris, because I had heard that she was Dahlia
4-1 Olga
4-2 I got spoiler'd so I knew it was her.
Not done with AJ either, yet.

Image
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title

Gender: Male

Rank: Prosecutor

Joined: Mon Sep 15, 2008 10:52 am

Posts: 603

Spoiler:
I was spoiled on most, here are the rest
1-1 obvious
1-2 see above (but it was weird because in one of the backgrounds on the menu White has grey hair but when he kills Mia he has purplish hair.
1-3 didn't know
1-4 Yogy
3-1 Dahlia, mostly because she was the only credible witness, plus her testimony was shot
3-5 Dahlia
4-2 Stickler

PEARL DIES TONIGHT
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Gender: Male

Location: Austria

Rank: Decisive Witness

Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 10:12 pm

Posts: 272

Spoiler: Ace Attorney
1-1 Sahwit, of course.
1-2 Because I didn't know that there would be a second trial, I kinda thought it was April May. Why? After a while, I thought "Wait, is this what the murderer looked like? I mean, she's pink-haired! I thought the killer was a guy. Hmph, my eyes probably fooled me."
1-3 I thought it was Oldbag at first, then Sal Manella, THEN Vasquez.
1-4 I didn't know who to suspect, until I saw Yanni Yogi. Actually, when I saw him, I didn't suspect him, until they talked about some guy called Yanni Yogi, and I kinda guessed he was the fisherman.
1-5 I kinda thought it was Lana.

Spoiler: Justice for All
2-1 Richard.
2-2 At first, Maya, then Ini...and THEN Mimi.
2-3 I kinda knew it was Acro as soon as I entered "Acro's Room", because he was the only one I haven't talked to at the time.
2-4 Adrian.

Spoiler: Trials and Tribulations
3-1 Dahlia, as soon as I saw her.
3-2 Uh, probably Desiree.
3-3 Furio Tigre, as soon as I saw him. I mean, who didn't know that immediately?
3-4 Dahlia!!
3-5 At first, I thought it was Iris (because I thought she was actually Dahlia).

Spoiler: Apollo Justice
4-1 When they asked me about who the murderer was, I actually had no idea. Even though it was kinda obvious, I thought it couldn't have been Gavin. But I also didn't think it was Olga.
4-2 Alita Tiala.
4-3 Daryan, because he was acting like an asshole all along.
4-4 Gavin, of course.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Gettin' Old!

Gender: Male

Location: Scotland

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:30 pm

Posts: 14363

Spoiler: AJ1 case 3
I thought it was Valant Gramayre, because of all the talk about the body just disappearing and the killer escaping I figured he'd used some magic trick to move them around so swiftly, I was wrong but he wasn't exactly innocent either. :hoboleft:

Made by Chesu+Zombee
Image

You thought you could be safe in your courts, with your laws and attorneys to protect you. In this world only I am law, my word is fact, my power is absolute.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Shoulda been Brawldude, but was taken

Gender: None specified

Location: A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away...

Rank: Medium-in-training

Joined: Thu Apr 09, 2009 12:11 am

Posts: 502

Ping' wrote:
Spoiler: everything
1-3 - Penny because if she were that useless they wouldn't have bothered making sprites for her. Turns out I was wrong, she really was useless.


No way! She gave Phoenix an URP!
Image
Click the sig to see my graphics topic!

My sig -is- original. Lots of people just make sigs similar to this one a lot.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Oh boy oh boy oh boy!

Gender: Male

Location: CA

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Fri Jun 12, 2009 1:26 am

Posts: 4993

Spoiler: EVERY SINGLE CASE
1-1: Obvious
1-2: I honestly thought that :redd: looked exactly like :sawit: during the case intro...
1-3: :cody-talk: I seriously thought he did it...
1-4: For the first part I knew it was :yogi: But when it got to the DL-6 part, I really thought :edgeworth: was the killer....
1-5: Actually I thought it would be :meekins:
2-1: Obvious
2-2: Ughh, this case was so confusing since throughout the whole thing I thought that Maya should not be guilty if she was doing the channeling. I don't even know who I thought was the killer.
2-3: I kinda knew it was :acro: because if you're the only normal guy at a circus, something is wrong with you.
2-4: :adrian: of course that's what they wanted all of us to think...
3-1: :zap:
3-2: Dessiree...
3-3: Um... :keiko: I mean :chef: I mean :zenitora:
3-4: I honestly thought the turnabout in this case would be that Melissa Foster was NOT :chinami: and that somehow somebody else was the killer...
3-5: After being horribly duped into thinking that Melissa was not Dahlia, I thought that Iris was Dahlia...thus she would be the killer...
4-1: :olga-quick: , srsly don't tell me you didn't think so too.
4-2: :noodle-hmm:
4-3: Valant, he was the most suspicious...
4-4: I thought it was :Brush-Sniff: but in the Phoenix part, I thought maybe :Temsai: killed himself

Image
Life's a Happy Song when there's someone by your side to sing along!
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

earthlings on fire

Gender: Female

Location: Hazakura Temple

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Tue Jul 14, 2009 12:57 am

Posts: 1014

Yaragorm wrote:
Spoiler: EVERY SINGLE CASE
1-1: Obvious
1-2: I honestly thought that :redd: looked exactly like :sawit: during the case intro...
1-3: :cody-talk: I seriously thought he did it...
1-4: For the first part I knew it was :yogi: But when it got to the DL-6 part, I really thought :edgeworth: was the killer....
1-5: Actually I thought it would be :meekins:
2-1: Obvious
2-2: Ughh, this case was so confusing since throughout the whole thing I thought that Maya should not be guilty if she was doing the channeling. I don't even know who I thought was the killer.
2-3: I kinda knew it was :acro: because if you're the only normal guy at a circus, something is wrong with you.
2-4: :adrian: of course that's what they wanted all of us to think...
3-1: :zap:
3-2: Dessiree...
3-3: Um... :keiko: I mean :chef: I mean :zenitora:
3-4: I honestly thought the turnabout in this case would be that Melissa Foster was NOT :chinami: and that somehow somebody else was the killer...
3-5: After being horribly duped into thinking that Melissa was not Dahlia, I thought that Iris was Dahlia...thus she would be the killer...
4-1: :olga-quick: , srsly don't tell me you didn't think so too.
4-2: :noodle-hmm:
4-3: Valant, he was the most suspicious...
4-4: I thought it was :Brush-Sniff: but in the Phoenix part, I thought maybe :Temsai: killed himself


You thought Gant killed Doug Swallow? :eh?:
ImageImageImage
...and there's fifteen feet of pure white snow
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

:)

Gender: Female

Location: UK

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 11:33 pm

Posts: 3478

Spoiler: For 2-3, well not really a suspicion but...
I wanted it to be Regina. I wanted to see an epic breakdown and all her cuteness just melts away! I liked Acro.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

ALL GLORY TO... SOMETHING

Gender: Male

Location: Not in a courtroom, that's where.

Rank: Prosecutor

Joined: Fri Apr 24, 2009 6:44 pm

Posts: 914

Cravat of Doom wrote:
Yaragorm wrote:
Spoiler: EVERY SINGLE CASE
1-1: Obvious
1-2: I honestly thought that :redd: looked exactly like :sawit: during the case intro...
1-3: :cody-talk: I seriously thought he did it...
1-4: For the first part I knew it was :yogi: But when it got to the DL-6 part, I really thought :edgeworth: was the killer....
1-5: Actually I thought it would be :meekins:
2-1: Obvious
2-2: Ughh, this case was so confusing since throughout the whole thing I thought that Maya should not be guilty if she was doing the channeling. I don't even know who I thought was the killer.
2-3: I kinda knew it was :acro: because if you're the only normal guy at a circus, something is wrong with you.
2-4: :adrian: of course that's what they wanted all of us to think...
3-1: :zap:
3-2: Dessiree...
3-3: Um... :keiko: I mean :chef: I mean :zenitora:
3-4: I honestly thought the turnabout in this case would be that Melissa Foster was NOT :chinami: and that somehow somebody else was the killer...
3-5: After being horribly duped into thinking that Melissa was not Dahlia, I thought that Iris was Dahlia...thus she would be the killer...
4-1: :olga-quick: , srsly don't tell me you didn't think so too.
4-2: :noodle-hmm:
4-3: Valant, he was the most suspicious...
4-4: I thought it was :Brush-Sniff: but in the Phoenix part, I thought maybe :Temsai: killed himself


You thought Gant killed Doug Swallow? :eh?:


I think he means he suspected a lightning bolt.
Image
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

STFU Kristoph, you're jealous. >:|

Gender: None specified

Location: My chair. LOLOLOLOL-Oh, i mean England.

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Sun Sep 13, 2009 12:23 am

Posts: 24

Spoiler: Ace Attorney
1-1: Easy peasy.
1-2: I actutally missed the part where It shows Redd's face because i dropped my stylus right when he hit Mia. I thought it was April, then Redd upon the twat punching me.
1-3: I suspected Will might be, but he seemed so nice, i knew it wasn't him. I ACTUALLY BELIEVED IT WAS CODY HACKINS. I thought he'd seen the Evil Magistrate, summoned up his fanboy powers and speared whatshisface.
1-4: I WAS SO SURE IT WAS EDGEWORTH. But after listening to him, i realised he was too awesome to be the killer. Although i felt like strangling him when he told me "I picked the gun up for no reason." I accused Lotta of shooting him Richard, and i don't know why. Yanni was the choice after he ran away.
DL-6: I believed in my heart it wasn't Edgeworth! When i remembered the vacation, i knew Manny had been shot, but i thought he had shot Gregory because he thought GREGORY HAD SHOT HIM.
1-5 I: SUSPECTED MARSHALL. Then Gant the second i found the jar and stuff in his locker.
SL-9: I thought it was Darke all the way until Lana's photo popped up. OMGWTFBBQ THE BLOOD IS ON HIS SHIRT *knew it was gant*


Spoiler: Justice For All
2-1: Welly, clearly. My name comes from the statement 'Mr. Wellington LOVES LARGE BANANAS!'
2-2: I was so frustrated, thinking "IT WAS THE SPIRIT J00 ASSHOLES!" until Ini/Mimi started freaking out.
2-3: Regina. Thought the innocence was an act. Mainly because she wasn't saddened by her dad's death. Bluffed all the way until I realized WHY the bust was missing.
2-4: I spoiled myself accidentally by seeing Matt claw his face off. I had no idea he was an evil bastich though.


I haven't played the others.
2-3:
Image
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Wherever you go, I will be there.

Gender: Female

Location: Tachibana Dynasty, Koga

Rank: Prosecutor

Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009 9:31 am

Posts: 718

Spoiler: Ace Attorney
Case 1: :sawit:
Case 2: :bling-bling:
Case 3: :pokeman:
Case 4: :edgeworth: ...*shot*
Case 5: :scientific: ...*shot again*


Spoiler: Justice for All
Case 1: :beef:
Case 2: :pearl: ...Amazing how I have three bullets emdebbed and I'm not dead.
Case 3: :regina:
Case 4: :mattphone:


Spoiler: Trials and Tribulations
Case 1: :that-b-word:
Case 2: :mareka:
Case 3: :zenitora:
Case 4: :chinami:
Case 5: :fire:


Spoiler: Apollo Justice
Case 1: :gambler:
Case 2: :minas:
Case 3: :veil:
Case 4: :draw:


Spoiler: Ace Attorney Investigations (MAJOR SPOILERS)
Case 1: :tennis:
Case 2: :gypsy:
Case 3: Himeko
Case 4: Himiko
Case 5: Shih-na

Image

Signature by Myself
Sister of BSX and ChocolateXCheese


Last edited by Dylia on Sat Sep 26, 2009 10:28 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Oh boy oh boy oh boy!

Gender: Male

Location: CA

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Fri Jun 12, 2009 1:26 am

Posts: 4993

GigaHand wrote:
Cravat of Doom wrote:
Yaragorm wrote:
Spoiler: EVERY SINGLE CASE
1-1: Obvious
1-2: I honestly thought that :redd: looked exactly like :sawit: during the case intro...
1-3: :cody-talk: I seriously thought he did it...
1-4: For the first part I knew it was :yogi: But when it got to the DL-6 part, I really thought :edgeworth: was the killer....
1-5: Actually I thought it would be :meekins:
2-1: Obvious
2-2: Ughh, this case was so confusing since throughout the whole thing I thought that Maya should not be guilty if she was doing the channeling. I don't even know who I thought was the killer.
2-3: I kinda knew it was :acro: because if you're the only normal guy at a circus, something is wrong with you.
2-4: :adrian: of course that's what they wanted all of us to think...
3-1: :zap:
3-2: Dessiree...
3-3: Um... :keiko: I mean :chef: I mean :zenitora:
3-4: I honestly thought the turnabout in this case would be that Melissa Foster was NOT :chinami: and that somehow somebody else was the killer...
3-5: After being horribly duped into thinking that Melissa was not Dahlia, I thought that Iris was Dahlia...thus she would be the killer...
4-1: :olga-quick: , srsly don't tell me you didn't think so too.
4-2: :noodle-hmm:
4-3: Valant, he was the most suspicious...
4-4: I thought it was :Brush-Sniff: but in the Phoenix part, I thought maybe :Temsai: killed himself


You thought Gant killed Doug Swallow? :eh?:


I think he means he suspected a lightning bolt.


Yeah, that. :edgy:
Image
Life's a Happy Song when there's someone by your side to sing along!
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title

wait WHAT?

Gender: Male

Location: Michigan, USA

Rank: Desk Jockey

Joined: Wed Sep 02, 2009 2:16 am

Posts: 124

Spoiler: every case
1-1 it was given to you
1-2 also given but i thought :grossburg: was involved as well
1-3 i thought sal did it or penny
1-4 :edgeworth: i really did then later :yogi:

2-1 given
2-2 this case heart my head i really thought :Mimi: ghost did it but then i found out :Mimi: did do it but she was not a ghost and :tea: helped
2-3 i hated this case i really did i had no clue what was going on
2-4 :adrian: really i did i know De Killar was the one that actualy did the killing but i thought she hired him then matt whent all evil phycho on us

3-1 lightning the :chinami: went crazy phycho bitch on us
3-2 Dessiree
3-3 i thought Armstrong did it mainly becuase he gave me nightmares
3-4 uhh this one was easy :chinami:
3-5 i was thinking iris did it then Godot got even more bad ass

4-1 :hobohodo: yup i thought Nick did it
4-2 Alita
4-3 Valant
4-4 (Nick's part) i thought valant killed magnifi
4-4 (Polly's Part) before Nick's part :doodle: after :Kristoph-hair:


i was off on almost all of them :gant:
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Gender: Female

Location: United States

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 4:09 pm

Posts: 2276

Spoiler: AA
1-1 :sawit: (It was so painfully obvious)
1-2 :redd: (Again, obvious)
1-3 :oldbag:
1-4 :edgeworth:
1-5 :lunches:


Spoiler: JFA
2-1 :wellington:
2-2 :Mimi:
2-3 :moe-laugh:
2-4 :adrian-crunch:


Spoiler: T&T
3-1 :that-b-word:
3-2 :mareka:
3-3 :flowsers:
3-4 :that-b-word:
3-5 :ayame:


Spoiler: AJ
4-1 :olga-catch:
4-2 :pasta:
4-3 :varanbaran:
4-4 :Brush-Sniff:
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

lying is bad

Gender: Male

Location: Ithaca, NY

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 3:34 pm

Posts: 1916

Spoiler: GS1-GS3
1-1: Sawhit.
1-2: Grossberg
1-3: That girl and then Sal
1-4: Suicide
1-5: I actually thought Lana was guilty.
2-1: Richard
2-2: I thought Maya actually did it
2-3: Regina
2-4: Adrian Andrews
3-1: Dahlia (obviously)
3-2: Luke Atmey (I got it right!)
3-3: Tigre (Obviously)
3-4: Dahlia (Obviously)
3-5: I was hoping Bikini or Maya did it, but this was the first case where I was undecided.

Image
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

OTTF?

Gender: Female

Location: Weld County, CO

Rank: Decisive Witness

Joined: Mon Sep 14, 2009 2:28 am

Posts: 172

Spoiler: 3-5
At first, I just assumed that Iris was either Dahlia or some random mountain channeler channeling Dahlia. So through most of the case, I figured she must be the killer.

Later in the case, when we got Maya back and it was clear she was protecting somebody in her testimony, my only thought was "Oh, god! Not Pearly!" The Godot thing really blindsided me.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

In Justice We Trust

Gender: Male

Location: Southern California

Rank: Admin

Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 6:31 pm

Posts: 4215

The First Turnabout: Frank Sahwit. He was suspicious from the start.
Turnabout Sisters: April May. For some reason, I thought she was really the killer and only disguised as a woman.
Turnabout Samurai: Penny Nichols. Oldbag clearly had no reason to kill Hammer, but I got the impression Nichols could have done it. Of course, my suspicions changed pretty quickly when Manella and Vasquez were introduced.
Turnabout Goodbyes: Initially, I suspected von Karma, though my suspicion switched to "Uncle" shortly after I ran into him.
Rise from the Ashes: Angel Starr. The way she behaved on the stand, as well as her obvious grudge against Lana, convinced me that she would do just about anything to hurt her--even kill an innocent person.

I spoiled myself on the other games, so I didn't have anyone to initially suspect.
Image
I'll always love you, Max.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Superpower: Logic

Gender: Male

Location: Waiting for Godot

Rank: Desk Jockey

Joined: Tue Aug 25, 2009 2:36 am

Posts: 94

Spoiler: AA, JFA, T&T
1-1: Sahwit, duh.

1-2: Also obviously Redd White. You can even see him do it in the intro.

1-3: I wasn't sure, really. Maybe Oldbag, lulz.

1-4: At first, I thought Edgeworth accidentaly shot him.

1-5: Gant, from the moment I saw him :gant:

2-1: Wellington.

2-2: I was tricked by the whole channeling thing. I thought Maya did it, while possessed by someone else of course.

2-3: Moe the sniper clown :moe-laugh:

2-4: The kidnapper, De Killer. He's an assassin, so it's clear.

3-1: Until I saw Dahlia, I had no idea. Phoenix couldn't have done it anyway.

3-2: As for the theft, definitely :yuusaku: . As for the murder, :aiga:

3-3: The chef... :chef:

3-4: Do I need to spell it out? :chinami:

3-5: :chinami:, in some way. I also thought Iris and Dahlia were the same person.

Image
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Squirtle!

Gender: Male

Location: All around Pennsylvania

Rank: Medium-in-training

Joined: Wed Oct 01, 2008 12:34 am

Posts: 490

Spoiler: gyakuten kenji
so i assume that not too many imported :D
Case 1: mr sports guy (cant remember his name and I'm on an ipod :D so no looking it up >_<)
Case 2: wakana shinirato
case 3 money guy's son (too feminine to exist in a game) (says max galactica)
case 4 detectve badou (and kazura working together)
case 5: carnage onred

Married to SnowWright! Father of Tornado of Souls!
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title

Just a random passerby

Gender: Male

Location: Hyrule

Rank: Prosecutor

Joined: Sun Mar 16, 2008 4:42 pm

Posts: 623

I'll list my AAI suspects too. This list was who I thought the killer was. Before I spoiled myself, I made predictions based on character bios and pictures on the AAI character page. Might as well try to guess the killer if I'm going to spoil myself. I'll probably do this for future AA games too. Here comes the spoiler tag.
Spoiler: AAI/GK killer spoiler alert ahead.
1. Makato(Portsman). He was the only logical choice for this case. 2. Zinc White. He looked suspicious. Also I thought his arts were forgeries.
3. Hikaru (I think that's his name Talking about The rich guy's son) For a rich kid's son, he looked and seemed too poor. He looks like a jerk too.
4. Badou. He just looked like a killer and a courrupted detective. Though Kazura was a accomplice. 5. Damian Hinge and Carnage Onred. These guys looked way to suspucious from the first time I saw their names and pictures. The character bios just added to the suspicion. Since they were heads of two warring nations, they couldn't be working together. I thought Damian killed one and Carnage the other.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Call me Ishmael.

Gender: Male

Location: Sweden

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Sun Apr 12, 2009 4:16 pm

Posts: 2434

Spoiler: Ace Attorney Investigations: Miles Edgeworth
1. Portsman (obviously)
2. Lablanc
3. No idea.
4. No idea.
5. Damian

Wife: sparkleranger78, daughter: feedmechocolate247
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

The one and only

Gender: Male

Location: Germany

Rank: Decisive Witness

Joined: Wed Dec 09, 2009 8:32 pm

Posts: 216

Oh, cool thread. :gant:

Spoiler: GS1
1-1: Frank Sahwit.
1-2: Some old man who never actually appeared in the game. That is because, when I saw White in the intro, he seemed like some old man to me.
1-3: Wendy Oldbag, and after the second day Dee Vasquez.
1-4: Yanni Yogi, because of spoilers. -.-
Classroom Trial: Some random kid.
DL-6: Miles Edgeworth or Yanni Yogi.
1-5: Jake Marshall... come on, he looked so suspicious.
SL-9: Joe Darke.


Spoiler: GS2
2-1: Richard Wellington.
2-2: Ini/Mimi Miney... the one who is alive.
2-3: Acro.
2-4: Shelly De Killer :P And I thought the client was Adrian.


Spoiler: GS3
3-1: :chinami:
3-2: Luke Atmey.
3-3: Furio Tigre.
3-4: Dahlia Hawthorne.
3-5: Godot... did I mention I hate spoilers?


Spoiler: GS4
4-1: Olga Orly, like the most of us.
4-2: Wocky's father, what was his name again?
4-3: First Lamiroir, then Daryan.
4-4: Spark Brushel.
Flashback/4-0: Valant Gramarye.


Spoiler: GK
GK-1: Jacques Portsman
GK-2: Zinc LeBlanc, since I thought "Hey, they say Wakana is famous, so she can't be the killer."
GK-3: Lauren Paups.
GK-4: I thought they killed each other, but later I thought it was Calisto Yew.
KG-8: Manny Coachen.
KG-8 II: Yeah, Mack Rell.
GK-5: Quercus Alba... who on earth called his theme song "Quercus Alba ~ The enemy that surpasses law"?! -.-

Image


Last edited by Tacas on Fri Mar 05, 2010 5:22 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

justice is always wright ;)

Gender: Male

Rank: Decisive Witness

Joined: Sun Feb 14, 2010 5:53 pm

Posts: 290

Spoiler: too lazy to say all of them
1-3 i had absolutly no idea and i never would have guessed it was devasques(sp?)
1-4 suicide
1-5 angel star,then gant
2-2 morgan fey
2-3 absolutly no idea,all of them at berry big circus were really nice poeple,even trilo couldn't do anything like that so long as he was controlled by ben
2-4 de killer,but with no phsych lock for asking if he was the killer i was 100% sure(for the first time,every other time i am 90% sure) that my client was innocent
3-2 i thought attmey was the theif and i never suspected anyone of the murder
3-3 :zenitora:
3-5 i thought it was pearl channeling dahlia,but godot being the killer was an extremly huge surprize
4-1 olga yarly
4-2 i saw that alita was suspicous but i never suspected anyone of murder,i was thunderstruck when i saw trucy accuse stickler,her claim was more wild than phoenix's claim's :sadshoe:
4-3 no one,untill lamiroir told us she heard daryan
4-4 brushel,i thought he was acting dumb just like yani yogi,i never would have thought a prisoner was the killer,it was really shocking to me
flashback 4-4 i thought it was valant,it didn't even occur to me that it was suicide


yup,i am bad at guessing,but it's a good thing as it make's you even more dramatically surprized than when you expect it :yogi:
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Gender: Male

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Fri Feb 26, 2010 8:06 pm

Posts: 20

Spoiler: Ace Attorney
1-1: Sahwit D:
1-2: Redd White :V
1-3: Dee Vasquez
1-4: Yanni Yogi
DL-6: No clue.
1-5: Lana Skye
SL-9: Ema Skye


Spoiler: Justice for All
2-1: Richard
2-2: Morgan
2-3: Regina, then I met Acro...
2-4: De Killer. (Didn't saw Engarde coming!)


Spoiler: Trials and Tribulations
3-1: Dahlia
3-2: Luke Atmey
3-3: Tigre (why did they show him on the intro?!, for fuck's sake!)
3-4: Melissa xD
3-5: Dahlia... srsly NEVER expected Godot


Spoiler: Apollo Justice
4-1: Olga. (OK, when it turned to be Kristoph, I literally said "OHGODOHGODOHGOD BEST FIRST CASE EVEEEERRR"
4-2: Stickler xD
4-3: Daryan... fuck LeTouse.
4-4: Kristoph. (*watches Intro* OH YOU.)
Flashback case: Zak


Spoiler: Investigations
GK-1: Portsman xd
GK-2: Spoiled myself :C
GK-3: Lance Amano, sooo ooobvioouss.
GK-4: Gumshoe I had no clue.
GK-5: Shih-na
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Ahh...Coffee...

Gender: Male

Location: EARTH

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Fri Oct 16, 2009 12:35 am

Posts: 1877

I don't remember what I thought for the first four games at the moment, so I'll do just AAI for now.

Spoiler: AAI
Case 1: Jaques Portsman (I did not see that coming!)
Case 2: Zinc Lablanc
Case 3: Lauren Paups
Case 4: THE JUDGE!!! But who I actually thought was Tyrell Badd (I'm so glad he wasn't.)
Case 5: Shi-Na

Image
Click my sig to see my YouTube channel! AA music is found here!
CarChaseCityMan and Arkillian's son, Franzika Von ehmpke5 ,Lida_Rose and angel_of_nature's brother.
"If you don't have any shadows, then you're not standing in the light."
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Boom!

Gender: Male

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Fri Jan 29, 2010 3:11 am

Posts: 9

I'm only on 3-2 right now, but its always been obvious who the killer is the moment I see their name. The're all so...punny. I escpecially like the names

Spoiler:
Dahlia Hawthorne. Full stop. My mind jump straight to The Black Dahlia. It was obvious, and then we met her. Then is was like having an anvil fall on my head.

"Demon" Gant, that is all

2-4 was easy as well, All the time I was playing the games I wondered why all my clients were innocent. Moment I saw the name Engarde it became obvious.

What's war good for?
Lots of stuff - EVE Online
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Relaxed

Gender: Male

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Mon Dec 21, 2009 1:34 pm

Posts: 2

Spoiler: Ace Attorney
1-1: Obvious
1-2: :redd: and :grossburg: I felt like Grossberg was being a bit too secretive
1-3: :cody-flash: Trying to help the Steel Samurai by killing his main enemy
1-4: :edgeworth: And we would never see him again...
1-5: :two-faced: Her testimony just seemed really strange to me

Spoiler: Justice For All
2-1: Obvious
2-2: :pizza: For obvious reasons
2-3: :acro: Although I had a tough time believing that
2-4: :adrian: A lot of people thought that

Spoiler: Tirals and Tribulations
3-1: I thought the telephone pole simply broke
3-2: :luke-side: Pretty simple
3-3 :zenitora: Another easy one
3-4: :chinami: ...easy
3-5: After so many easy ones, I finally got to a point where I had no clue.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

1000% Knight

Gender: Male

Rank: Moderators

Joined: Tue Jun 17, 2008 2:06 pm

Posts: 6932

Spoiler: AAI
I TOTALLY THOUGHT IT WAS MAGGEY. IT WASN'T OBVIOUS WHO IT REALLY WAS AT ALL

I spoiled myself on Cammy =\

Once it became obvious that Lauren was the killer, it was obvious that Lance was the killer. (By process of elimination, really)

I didn't think it was Badd, so Calisto was left

I thought Shih-na had actually murdered Manny. (Although I believed her when she said she didn't.) I liked Colias too much for him to be guilty :3 so I figured it was Quercus.



Also, I hate to be that guy, but I just realized it should be whom...
Image
Credit to Evolina for the sig+avatar!
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

I are the duck.

Gender: Male

Location: Where all the good people go.

Rank: Medium-in-training

Joined: Thu Jun 25, 2009 4:09 pm

Posts: 367

Spoiler: Ace Attorney
1-1: Sahwit, obviously, the game shows you.
1-2: Redd White, same as above.
1-3: Sal Manella, I was convinced his 'nerdiness' was an act.
1-4: Manfred Von Karma, for both murders. Come on, he's TOO evil!
1-5: Angel Starr, I assumed she had a grudge against Lana, and was trying to frame her. Until I explored Gant's office, of course...


Spoiler: Justice For All
2-1: Wellington, the game gives it away, obviously.
2-2: Ini Miney, it was sort of obvious. I didn't suspect Morgan, though.
2-3: Regina. That was actually quite a clever one, it seems to have fooled a lot of people.
2-4: Adrian Andrews, who else? The Engarde thing was a shock.


Spoiler: Trials and Tribulations
3-1: Dahlia. There wasn't anyone else left to suspect!
3-2: I knew Atmey would be the theif, but the killer? I had no clue. I liked Atmey...
3-3: TIGRE! Such an obvious one.
3-4: Dahlia!! Soon as I saw her. Duh.
3-5: I had no idea. UNTIL SOMEONE SPOILED ME GAWRHHHH!!!!


Spoiler: Apollo Justice
4-1: Olga Orly. In retrospect, I think 4-1 is my favourite AJ case. Genius twist!
4-2: I was semi-convinced that Wocky had done it...?
4-3: I started off suspected Lamiroir. As the case progressed, I slowly moved from Lamiroir to Daryan. I really, REALLY wanted Daryan to be innocent. He was my favourite 4-3 character.
4-4: Kristoph. It seemed obvious that we weren't done with him.
4-(flashback): I knew it was suicide, as soon as 'Gumpowder burns' appeared in the autopsy.


Spoiler: Ace Attorney Investigations
5-1: Portsman - which is a shame, I liked Portsman.
5-2: Cammy! It was like a second Ini Miney.
5-3: Lauren, I suspected her as soon as I saw her. Quite a twist, this one.
5-4: Detective Badd. Come on, HE'S BAD(D)! Once again, I really like the killer here...
5-5: Shih-Na, and Colias. I also breifly suspected Lang (while he was accusing Fransiska!)

Image

Credit for the above goes to this person here.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Steel Samourai's Fan

Gender: Female

Location: Stalking Will Powers...

Rank: Decisive Witness

Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2010 4:35 pm

Posts: 169

Spoiler: PW:AA
1- :sawit: It was just too obvious...
2- :april: I kinda like :redd: so I didn't want him to be the murderer...
3- :sal: Well, he's the only one I could think of, but maybe it's just because I hate him...
4- :edgeworth: I didn't liked him at first... And I didn't want it to be :karma: since he's one of my favorite character... And I never tough it could be :yogi: ...
5- :lunches: or :lana: I didn't wanted :damon: to be the murderer, he was one of my favorite character!!!


Spoiler: PW: AA2
1- :wellington: It was too obvious...
2- I was sure it was :morgan:!
3- :punch-ben: At first, I though Trilo was evil... I still think that he's evil, but now I know that he wasn't the murderer..
4- I knew it was :shelly: the first time I've seen him, because it's ALWAYS the butler!!! And I'm right! Though :enguard!: was his client, he is the real murderer in this case!!!


Spoiler: PW:AA3
1- Actually, I was sure it was only an accident...
2- :yuusaku: I liked :inspect: and I though Ron acted too suspicious to be totally innocent...
3- :igarashi: then :flowsers: I didn't wanted :zenitora: to be the murderer, I like him.
4- :chinami: After what happened in the first case...
5- Well, I was sure that :ayame: was :delilah-hair: so I though she was the murderer...


I'll add the others later...
Godot and his coffee cup, an eternal love!
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

The Bitch Prosecutor

Gender: Female

Location: Hobohodo's cardboard box.

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Sun Mar 07, 2010 4:09 pm

Posts: 19

Ace Attorney
Spoiler:
1-1: Sawhit
1-2: White.
1-3: I had a hard time with this one. I first thought Oldbag for the longest time, but then I said Dee Vasquez. When I met her, I totally knew.
1-4: The "noodle shop owner", but I suspected Edgeworth for when he confessed in the second part.
1-5: Angel Starr, then Jake Marshall, THEN Gant.


Justice for All
Spoiler:
2-1: Wellington.
2-2: Morgan Fey, but then I got confused with the whole Mimi/Ini thing going on, so I just started presenting shit that made no sense until we figured out that Mimi was really Ini. Whatever.
2-3: .....Max. *is shot*
2-4: FUCKING ADRIAN ANDREWS. THEN I PRESENTED THE WRONG EVIDENCE AT THE END AND GOT THE BAD ENDING. FUCK.


Trials and Tribulations: Sadly, I have not beat this one yet, and I won't give a full thing until I'm done!

Apollo Justice
Spoiler:
4-1: I honestly thought Olga did it for the longest time. When Kristoph was suspected, I got mad because already he had become my fave character in the game.
4-2: Stickler.
4-3: :haha: When I first figured out about the recoil and then about the mixing board, that was it.
4-4: I hate this case. It was so obvious as to who did it. :pft:

"Perhaps a fifth person came and took it out? Oh, and a sixth person could've helped!"- Kristoph Gavin

Image <---- The Coolest Defense in the West.
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

SHADOW AND TRUCY!!!

Gender: Male

Rank: Desk Jockey

Joined: Fri Feb 05, 2010 3:25 am

Posts: 69

Never actually played AA (Still want to though)

Spoiler: JFA
2-1: Obvious
2-2: Who DIDN'T suspect Ini?
2-3: Thought it was Ben, He seemed too Nervous
2-4: I had a suspussion when Shelly called Nick Swearing Matt was innocent


Spoiler: TnT
3-1: Obvious
3-2: Though I Watched online, My thoughts were that Luke was the theif, but Dessie was the killer.
3-3: Tigre was Obvious, but I thought Jean had more involvement than he did.
3-4: Again, Obvious
3-5: I initially thought Iris WAS Dahlia, so I was hoping Larry would be arrested so that we could PROVE her guilt. But Once Mia said it was someone who Wasn't at the Initial Investigation, I Started to think Godot


Spoiler: AJ
4-1: Olga, I thought she HAD to have done it, Even when Nick claimed it was Kristoph, I didn't believe him
4-2: I Was actually thinking either Plum or Wesley
4-3: Initially I was thinking Lamiroir, she just had that air about her, Even when she turned out to be blind, I wasn't sure
4-4: I was very confused until The section with Nick, then I started to think Kristoph again

Image
Thank's to Maggey for the Sig and Avatar

Image
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title

i'll get an avvy later

Gender: Male

Location: blarg

Rank: Medium-in-training

Joined: Sat Nov 28, 2009 1:46 am

Posts: 360

every single first witness (excluding gumshoe and case 3-3, and obviously 2-4)
Spoiler: All AA games
the following people are EEEEEEEVIL:
karma, gant, morgan le fey, slashface aka engarde, penguin/atmey, black dahlia, and devil's hand (aka hirohiko aka figure it out yourself)
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Consider this puzzle solved.

Gender: Male

Location: Isn't it obvious?

Rank: Decisive Witness

Joined: Sun Feb 07, 2010 1:43 am

Posts: 294

Spoiler: GS1
Case 1: Guess
Case 2: :redd:
Case 3: :devasque:
Case 4: :yogi:
DL-6: :edgeworth:
Case 5: :damon: or :two-faced:

Spoiler: JFA
Case 1: Guess
Case 2: :knock-knock:
Case 3: :acro:
Case 4: :adrian:

Spoiler: T&T
Case 1: Lightning
Case 2: For the robbery :luke-side: , and for the murder :luke-side: . I knew the game would pull it off somehow.
Case 3: :zenitora:
Case 4: Guess
Case 5: :chinami: , being channeled.

Spoiler: AJ
Case 1: :olga-quick:
Case 2: :takita:
Case 3: :pencileraser:
Case 4: :Kristoph-hair: (How could you NOT get this one? They show him to you in the intro, just as they do Tigre in 3-3. I don't understand how anybody could have guessed those two wrong.)

Say, that reminds me of a puzzle! Have you ever heard this one, Luke?
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

earthlings on fire

Gender: Female

Location: Hazakura Temple

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Tue Jul 14, 2009 12:57 am

Posts: 1014

IHATECLOUD, let me just take the opportunity to say I love everything about your signature.

Ahem.

Spoiler: AAI.
Case 1- GUMSHOE! *shot*
Case 2 - Damn spoilers. But I knew it was going to be Meele anyway.
Case 3- Lauren
Case 4- Detective Badd
Case 5- I haven't finished it yet, but I know who it is.(SPOILERS! GRAAH!) Though I was suspecting Shih-na.

ImageImageImage
...and there's fifteen feet of pure white snow
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title

Gender: Female

Location: In front of my computer

Rank: Suspect

Joined: Tue Mar 02, 2010 12:29 am

Posts: 33

Spoiler: AA
1-1 and 1-2: obvious
1-3:Ummmm...yea...I actually thought it was Cody at first (He has a sword!! Even though its probably fake...) When I saw Dee though I knew it was her
1-4: I guessed the boatshop guy/Yanni Yogi
1-5: I knew it was Damon due to random spoilers :sadshoe:

Spoiler: JFA
2-1: Wellington. Who else could it be?
2-2: Ini/Mimi. Even down to the whole Ini=Mimi thing (Though the last part I only got when I saw Ini/Mimi's sprite with her twirling the hat, because I could see that her eyes looked EXACTLY like Mimi's from the profile picture). I didn't really suspect Morgan though (Even if she did scare me...)
2-3: I thought it was Regina since she didn't seem to give a crap about her father's death. I was wrong though, she's just ignorant and stupid
2-4: Adrian. The game kinda makes you think that...

Spoiler: T&T
3-1: Dahlia. She's the only witness, and she's just way too "innocent"
3-2: I actually thought Ron did it both times (At first I thought he was Mask*DeMasque but then thought he was the murderer)
3-3: Tigre. If I remember correctly, they show him in the intro
3-4: Guess
3-5:...Honestly, I had no idea what was going on at first. I switched suspects a thousand times. First I thought Iris (Naturally thinking she was Dahlia), then Bikini (Only for a moment though), then back to Iris after she ran away from Edgey, then Pearls (Of course I knew it wouldn't be intentional if she did it), then Dahlia, and finally Godot when you start accusing him
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Gender: Female

Location: United States

Rank: Ace Attorney

Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 4:09 pm

Posts: 2276

Spoiler: AAI
1 Portsman. It was painfully obvious.
2 LeBlanc.
3 Lauren
4 Badd
5 Shi-na
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

evil monkey is watching you.

Gender: Male

Location: U.S. of A.

Rank: Desk Jockey

Joined: Sun Mar 14, 2010 12:05 am

Posts: 86

Here's the one's that caught me off guard.

Spoiler: everything
1-5: I honestly thought Lana was gonna be our first guilty defendant.
2-2: thought it was Ini, but didn't see the identity twist coming.
2-4: As for De Killer's client: I was clueless because nobody really fit (thanks to that mis-leading lack of Psyche Locks >.<) 3-1: Again clueless. Just couldn't bring myself to suspect Dahlia xP
3-5:Thought that Iris was really Dahlia (until it was mentioned that dahlia had a twin sister). Then I suspected....I don't know, Bikini?
4-1: Olga seemed obvious at first with it being the intro case and all.
4-2: thought it was Guy until clues started pointing to Alita.
AAI:
case 4: I suspected Coachen at first, then Yew, but definitely didn't see her being the Yatagarasu.
case 5: I suspected Palaeno *SHOT by angry mob of fangirls*

Image
I PITY THE FOO'S FOO WHO FOOLS FOOS WHO FOOLISHLY ACCEPT THE FOOLISHNESS OF A FOO'S FOO.........FOO!
Re: Who did you suspect?Topic%20Title
User avatar

Save poor Gumshoe!

Gender: Male

Location: The Netherlands

Rank: Desk Jockey

Joined: Mon Mar 01, 2010 5:12 pm

Posts: 112

Spoiler: AA
1-1 :sawit:
1-2 :redd:
1-3 :devasque:
1-4 :yogi:
1-5 :damon: when i saw him for the first time, before that :two-faced:


Spoiler: JFA
2-1 :beef:
2-2 :pizzahat:
2-3 :sob:
2-4 :shoe:, not really. I mean :mattphone:


Spoiler: TnT
3-1 :chinami:
3-2 :aiga:
3-3 :zenitora:
3-4 :chinami:
3-5 :chinami:


Spoiler: AJ
1-1 :olga-catch:
1-2 :mina:
1-3 :haha:
1-4 :violin:


Spoiler: AAI
1 :tennis:
2 Cammy Meele
3 Lance Almando
4 Calisto Yew, How could you laugh after a murder happened?
5 Querques Alba

"The only time a lawyer can cry, is when it's all over" ~ Godot.
Page 2 of 4 [ 149 posts ] 
Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  

 Board index » Phoenix Wright » Defendant's Lobby

Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 17 guests

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum
Jump to:  
cron
News News Site map Site map SitemapIndex SitemapIndex RSS Feed RSS Feed Channel list Channel list
Powered by phpBB

phpBB SEO